Thursday, April 29, 2010

Path Dependence?

I am currently in Minneapolis. It is, to me, a great city. My feelings may reflect that it was the large city nearest to me when I was growing up, but they also reflect that it has the attributes of a great city: innovative companies, such as 3M, and Medtronic, wonderful arts, including an orchestra that Alex Ross of the New Yorker wrote,"[sounds] to my ears, like the greatest orchestra in the world," and a vibrant, walkable downtown. The only other Midwestern city with such a jewel of a downtown is Chicago, which is also, of course, a much larger city.

The question is why. Bill Cronon wrote a great book about Chicago, explaining how it became and remains an epic city. The remain part is a function of path dependence--once Chicago made a set of choices about how it would connect with the nature that surrounded it, both physically (through, for instance, railroads) and intellectually (through, for instance, exchanges), it set itself on a self-perpetuating path.

I know of no similar book about the Twin Cities (that doesn't mean it doesn't exist). But it is an interesting question as to why Minneapolis has done so much better than other Midwest metropolitan areas: it terms of educational attainment, income, and population growth, it has substantially outperformed Kansas City, St Louis, Milwaukee, Cleveland, Cincinnati, Toledo, Dayton, Pittsburgh and Buffalo (I could go on, but you get the point). I don't think it is the weather.

6 comments:

Unknown said...

I have discovered your website by accident and I think it´s wonderful! Very practical and filled with useful information!
credit card for bad credit

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

Unlike a selling agent, a property buyers agent acts exclusively and independently for a property buyer. A buyers agent will give you the best advice on how and where to buy a property that will suit your requirements. And if you are unsure of what to look for or simply don’t have the time, a buyers agent will inspect and short list suitable properties for you. A buyers agent is able to look for property in a wide range of locations from various different sources, unlike a selling agent who works in a specific area. They will also negotiate the best purchase price for you and ensure that the process of selecting and purchasing a property right through until settlement is a smooth and hassle free experience.
With offices in Sydney and Brisbane, Prosper Group are the Australian property buyers agents of choice for busy professionals. If you are considering buying a home or an investment property and need advice or require assistance with finding and negotiating the right property; call Prosper Group and speak with a qualified property buyers agent on 1300 664 373 or email us on enquiries@prospergroup.com.au

Cathy Mena said...

A person should take a deep breath and try to find something to do for a few minutes to get their mind off of the current situation. A person could take a walk, listen to some music, read the newspaper or do an activity that will give them a fresh perspective on things.
real estate

Unknown said...

I've been to Chicago twice and its a fine city. This seems to be an interesting book.

Buyers Advocates Melbourne

Unknown said...

Television is not real life. In real kithg86 life people actually have to leave
the coffee shop and go to jobs.
Cheap New Era Hats

New Era 59fifty Hats

New Era 59fifty caps

New Era Hats Wholesale

Cheap Hats