Thursday, May 08, 2008

Richard Arnott finds a conundrum for making housing policy in developing countries

The abstract for his paper for the Commission on Growth:

All countries have a formal economy and an informal economy. But, on
average, in developing countries the relative size of the informal sector is considerably larger than in developed countries. This paper argues that this has important implications for housing policy in developing countries. That most poor households derive their income from informal employment effectively precludes income-contingent transfers as a method of redistribution. Also, holding fixed real economic activity, the larger is the relative size of the informal sector, the lower is fiscal capacity, and the more distortionary is government provision of a given level of goods and services, which restricts the desirable scale and scope of government policy. For the same reasons, housing policies that have proven successful in developed countries may not be successful when employed
in developing countries.


Particularly problematic is the fact that the best static housing policy would be to provide water and sewage infrastructure for informal settlements. But the provision of such services reduces the incentives for the settlement to become formal. Until the settlements are formal, the fiscal capacity of governments will remain low, so their ability to provide infrastructure will be limited.

Tuesday, May 06, 2008

Best Line on Russian History I heard today

My daughter Hannah on Lenin:

"His greatest success was dieing while he was still ahead."

I think they're going to like her at Northwestern next fall.

Bad News from Fannie Mae today

The GSE lost another $2.2 billion. It is not clear to me whether this includes new accounting treatment for bad loans--if it is no long considering loans that are 120 days late to be impaired, the number is even worse than it looks.

At least this will compel Fannie to cuts its dividend and raise capital.

Sunday, May 04, 2008

If Hillary really cared about low income workers...

She would call for a temporary reduction in the payroll tax, rather than the gas tax (hat tip to an anonymous friend who wishes to remain that way). This would reduce the burden of higher gas prices, while continuing to discourage gasoline consumption, something that is obviously desirable for both the environment and national security.

Worse than her bad policy is her recent fusillade against "experts." I liked her sleazy husband's administration because it actually relied on experts for making policy, and so made the country stronger economically. Moreover, low-income workers did better during the Clinton administration than in any other since the 1960s (and according to Joseph Stiglitz (link coming), better than the 60s, but according to Eric Olin Wright, not quite as well as the 60s). But to have Clintonian ethics without expertise--no thank you.

If Clinton does by some miracle win the nomination, I will hold my nose and vote for her. But the clothespin I will need is getting bigger every day.

Saturday, May 03, 2008

A Nice, Clear Critique of Hypothesis Testing

Students at times come to my office to tell me that their professors in research methods courses emphasize the importance of null hypotheses and hypothesis testing. It always brings to mind the last words Gary Chamberlain said in his econometrics class: "I didn't mention hypothesis testing, because I don't like it. And don't ever use those damned stars." [I am, of course, paraphrasing, as I took the class 25 years ago].

In any event, I ran across this nice critique of hypothesis testing. The point of statistics, after all, should be parameter estimation and prediction, not some arbitrary test of statistical significance. In large samples, statistically significant parameters can be unimportant; in small samples, statistically insignificant parameters can simply mean that we don't really know what is going on.

Much of the confusion underlying how medical information is conveyed in the media arises from the hypothesis testing tradition: the media infer that if x is a statistically significant predictor of y, then x must be important in determining y. This is not necessarily so.

Friday, May 02, 2008

Worth Contemplating as Ethanol Subsidies contribute to Rising Food Prices

Time's What the World Eats.

Check out the family from Chad. Consider what happens to them when grain prices double.

USA Today says College Students are Spending More--without getting more

Yesterday's story is based on this report. The change is particularly pronounced at public universities, in part because cuts in state funding have required sharp increases in tuition.

I am personally conflicted about how much to subsidize students at State U. One of the things I loved about the University of Wisconsin when I taught there was that it provided access to a great education to anyone in Wisconsin who qualified academically. (when I began on the faculty in 1990, tuition was very inexpensive at about $2,000). Now in-state tuition there is about $7,000 per year. At this price, it is still a bargain, in the sense that it provides extraordinary value per dollar spent, but it has become sufficiently expensive that it turns some students away because of financial considerations. And this is a shame.

On the other hand, the life-time income of UW grads is, on average, much higher than the life-time income of Wisconsin taxpayers. It is reasonable to ask whether lower income people should be subsidizing higher income people. But on the other hand (again) the spillover benefits of having college graduates is large (see Ed Glaeser and others on this point). As I said, I am conflicted...

Monday, April 28, 2008

Joe Cortright says that higher gas prices are hurting suburbs and places without strong urban cores

He writes:
...high gas prices are not only implicated in the bursting of the housing bubble, but that the higher cost of commuting has already re-shaped the landscape of real estate value between cities and suburbs. Housing values are falling fastest in distant suburban and exurban neighborhoods where affordability depended directly on cheap gas. In metro areas around the country, housing prices are down most on the fringe, while close-in neighborhoods are holding more of their value--or in several cases, still continuing to see price appreciation.
And the analysis also shows that those metropolitan areas with the strongest close-in neighborhoods--as measured by the core vitality index we developed in our 2006 City Vitals report--have weathered the housing collapse far better than other metros. House prices have performed best and foreclosures have been lower in those metropolitan areas with vibrant core neighborhoods.

Far from being a short term or transitory event, our view is that this shift in real estate market valuations implies a fundamentally different path for future urban development in the years ahead. As my colleague, CEO's for Cities President Carol Coletta puts it, "In short, vibrant cities just became a whole lot more valuable."

There are tremendous opportunities for the nation's cities to build on this shift in value, promoting redevelopment, mixed uses, higher densities and better transit. These strategies will also play a key role in helping reduce energy demand (and the trade deficit) as well as putting us on a path to dealing with the challenge of global warming.


The paper has lots of interesting pictures relating location to changes in house prices. But I think a key policy question is whether "strong urban cores" can be created by design, or whether they are organic phenomena.

Sunday, April 27, 2008

Peter Gordon on Phillip Roth (Zuckerman) on George Plimpton

Peter Gordon writes:

Philip Roth's Exit Ghost is enjoyable for many reasons. Roth even gives us a thumbnail definition of happiness. Nathan Zuckerman had been on self-imposed exile in the Berkeshire's and, on re-entering New York city life, is stunned to discover that George Plimpton had died.

George escaped his glamour without losing his glamour, only
further enhancing it in autobiographical books seemingly driven by
self-deprecation. Climbing into the ring with Archie Moore he is
simply practicing noblesse oblige in its most exquisite form -- a form,
moreover that he had invented. When people say to themselves 'I want to be
happy,' they could as well be saying 'I want to be George Plimpton': one
achieves, one is productive, and there's pleasure and ease in all of it. (p.
250).


I remember reading Paper Lion when I was around 10. At the time, I thought it was the best thing I had ever read.

(Vertical) transportation and urban form:

Nick Paumgarten in the New Yorker:

In New York City, home to fifty-eight thousand elevators, there are eleven billion elevator trips a year—thirty million every day—and yet hardly more than two dozen passengers get banged up enough to seek medical attention. The Otis Elevator Company, the world’s oldest and biggest elevator manufacturer, claims that its products carry the equivalent of the world’s population every five days. As the world urbanizes—every year, in developing countries, sixty million people move into cities—the numbers will go up, and up and down.

Two things make tall buildings possible: the steel frame and the safety elevator. The elevator, underrated and overlooked, is to the city what paper is to reading and gunpowder is to war. Without the elevator, there would be no verticality, no density, and, without these, none of the urban advantages of energy efficiency, economic productivity, and cultural ferment. The population of the earth would ooze out over its surface, like an oil slick, and we would spend even more time stuck in traffic or on trains, traversing a vast carapace of concrete. And the elevator is energy-efficient—the counterweight does a great deal of the work, and the new systems these days regenerate electricity. The elevator is a hybrid, by design.

Admissions Advice

This week I read Susan Coll's Admissions, which reminded me of my time as MBA Dean at GW. We had an excellent admissions staff with fine judgment, but they would sometimes ask my opinion about close calls. I remember one mediocre candidate who began his essay with something along the lines of "when people work for me." He then proceeded to describe what everyone would do for him--nothing about what he would do for them. He basically showed himself to be the sort of person with whom no one would wish to work.

So my advice to those writing admission essays: don't be a putz.

Saturday, April 26, 2008

The New York Times is (some days) a National Treasure

Barry Bearek's story of his imprisonment for trying to cover the elections in Zimbabwe is both harrowing and informative. The final two paragraphs:

I had left the cells with a case of scabies, an infestation of microscopic mites that swelled my hands and wrists to nearly twice their size. But I am better now, back in Johannesburg, with Celia, with our sons, Max, 17, and Sam, 12.

In the meantime, Zimbabwe is beset with paroxysms of violence. Thuggery, torture and murder are familiar implements in Robert Mugabe’s tool kit. Political opponents are being brutalized, as are everyday people whose voting defied him. The presidential election results are still unannounced.


A blogger whom I esteem often entitles his posts "New York Times Death Spiral," and then gives examples of the paper's shortcomings. But all journalism is compromised by tight deadlines; journalists also need to play a repeated game with sources, which means they cannot be heroic and write whatever they are thinking every day.

To me, the Times balances the need for timeliness and access against its moral obligation to be courageous as well as any newspaper. It gets the balance wrong from time-to-time. But I remain grateful for its existence.

Friday, April 25, 2008

A Pox on All Three (but the biggest, grossest on McCain)

All three candidates are pandering about gasoline prices. McCain is the worst, having called for a gas tax holiday in the summer, when pollution is at its worst.

Now comes a story from Businessweek that suggests that, contrary to the findings in David Austin's work, higher gas prices are leading to less driving. It would be hard to list all the policy benefits that result from this.

We do need to be careful about the association here--people may be driving less because they are less likely to be working, or because they are not going shopping or out to eat as much. If the reduction is driving owes more to the likely recession than to the price of gasoline, the effect will not be permanent. We won't be able to figure out which it is until and unless the economy bounces back at the same time that the price of gas remains high.

The regressive nature of high gas prices is also a problem. But this would be better solved through increases in the minimum wage and/or the earned income tax credit than a reduction in the federal gasoline tax.

Thursday, April 24, 2008

It is going to be awhile before the economy recovers

From the Washington Post:

Sales of New Single-Family Homes at 16-Year Low

I wrote ten years ago that residential construction was THE leading indicator. And Ed Leamer says housing IS the business cycle. Yikes!

dilemmas

My Wall Street Journal subscription is about to expire. I don't know whether to renew. One the one hand, I hate sending money to Rupert Murdoch. On the other, I would miss Greg Ip, David Wessel and Scott McCartney. And the editorial page is one of two places I allow myself to be exposed to right-wing nuttery (Bill Kristol's column is the other).

[update: I've decided to renew].

Wednesday, April 23, 2008

Polonius on Subprime

Hamlet, Act I Scene III

Neither a borrower, nor a lender be;
For loan oft loses both itself and friend,
And borrowing dulls the edge of husbandry.


Of course, Polonius was an ass.

Twelfth Night Commercial 3

With the Green sisters. Successors to the Coen Brothers.

Diane Swonk Waxes Poetically about Falling House Prices

She writes:

[The housing downturn] not only represents a hit to the American economy, but it represents a hit to the American psyche. It is a straw that breaks the back of working class households who feel they have already given more than their fair share in an economy that penalizes manual labor relative to educational attainment.


A more prosaic way to put it is that home equity is often the only wealth that people in the lower half of the income distribution have. According to the 2004 SCF, 40 percent of those in the bottom quintile of the income distribution have some home equity; only 12 percent own stock.

The prescience of JM Keynes

This via Brad Delong:

The outstanding ground for cheerfulness lies, I think, in this -- that the system has shown already its capacity to stand an almost inconceivable strain. If anyone had prophesied to us a year or two ago the actual state of affairs which exists to-day, could we have believed that the world could continue to maintain even that degree of normality which we actually have? This remarkable capacity of the system to take punishment is the best reason for hoping that we still have time to rally the constructive forces of the world.


Remarkable.

Tuesday, April 22, 2008

Schools and Property Values

One of my good GW friends, knowing that my daughters had just finished navigating the college admissions process, lent me her copy of Acceptance, a novel about crazed parents and their slightly less crazed children going through the college application process in a fictitious Maryland county that just happens to contain the National Institutes for Health. The novel is quite funny, and one passage stood out:

Her public school might as well have been a private school, and in a way, it was. There was no tuition, per se, but irrational real estate prices served to filter out most of the rabble and ;end it a somewhat exclusive air, or so she'd heard her mother say.


This paragraph summarizes why I support school choice. Affluent people have school choice--they can pay for private school, or they can move to places with excellent public schools (whose excellence is capitalized into land prices). Meanwhile, kids of poor families are stuck in dysfunctional school districts with no place to go. Just spending money on these schools doesn't seem to solve the problem--DC has among the highest expenditures per pupil of any school district in the country, yet by any reasonable measure, their performance, particularly at the high school level, is dreadful. Kids in DC should be allowed to attend schools in Montgomery and Fairfax Counties.