Friday, October 16, 2009

What is the optimal Rock Star status for a professor?

Greg Mankiw's blog led me to a piece in the Harvard Crimson on three of Harvard's most popular professors: Mankiw himself, Robert Lue and Niall Ferguson. The opening paragraph:

When History Professor Niall C. D. Ferguson begins his lecture at 10:07 a.m., he abandons the podium, choosing instead to pace in a slow, deliberate loop around the lectern. He speaks with the kind of proper British accent that makes Anglophiles swoon. As he makes an argument about the French Revolution, his throat wraps around certain words with a silky aggression that he punctuates by cocking an eyebrow or gesturing with his left hand, index finger and thumb closed into an “o” around a stub of chalk. His words are actually improvised. His paper schedule book, full of cross-country speaking engagements, is not.


The article also makes clear that Mankiw and Lue are around and available for students all the time, and they are well known. But from the perspective of undergraduate education, what is better--to have a famous professor who gives good lectures who is rarely around, or to have a not so famous professor who gives good lectures who is always around?

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

I love the content on your blog. But the comment section tends to be filled with spam. Askimet has free software that eliminates this problem. If you used it, I think it would help to strengthen the comment section of your blog.

http://akismet.com/

Anonymous said...

正享除蟲服務項目:白蟻防治,跳蚤防治,蛀蟲防治,燻蒸防治,蟑螂防治,老鼠防治,蚊子防治,蒼蠅防治,螞蟻防治,蛾蚋防治,園藝防治.
正享是專業的白蟻白蟻防治、除蟲專家,提供消除白蟻、白蟻防治、以及除蟲服務,只要您有惱人的白蟻困擾,找正享除蟲就對了。

Anonymous said...

正享除蟲服務項目:白蟻防治,跳蚤防治,蛀蟲防治,燻蒸防治,蟑螂防治,老鼠防治,蚊子防治,蒼蠅防治,螞蟻防治,蛾蚋防治,園藝防治.
正享是專業的白蟻白蟻防治、除蟲專家,提供消除白蟻、白蟻防治、以及除蟲服務,只要您有惱人的白蟻困擾,找正享除蟲就對了。

Arnold Chu said...

I rather think that it depends on the major and subject matter of the course. If the professor can actually improve her/his teaching by means of the travel for speech/consulting/research, then it may be preferable. Example might include business, modern arts, etc. Other the other hand, if the topic is ancient rhetorics or history, then I think the travel time might not be well spent.

zhuzhulee said...

PDF Créateur
TIFF en PDF Convertisseur
Texte en PDF Convertisseur
PowerPoint en PDF Convertisseur
image en PDF convertisseur
Excel en PDF Convertisseur
CHM en PDF Convertisseur
Word en PDF Convertisseur
djvu to pdf
pdf to png